My 9/11 Video

[Dural]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ7uFA8RwpQ

This could be the final version, I'm looking for feedback. A higher quality version can be downloaded here...

http://rapidshare.de/files/18600723/911_vendetta5.wmv.html

[Gold9472]

Dural... this is VERY creative. Great job!

[Gold9472]

I'm assuming those images were from "Vendetta". I didn't see it yet. It was very creatively done.

[Dural]

Because you haven't seen the movie, I'm curious as to whether the timeline and story has consistency and makes sense.

[Gold9472]

Because you haven't seen the movie, I'm curious as to whether the timeline and story has consistency and makes sense.

It made sense to me. I'm not that bright though.

[Gold9472]

If you want an honest critiquing, then I'll watch it again, and look for flaws... the first time is out of curiousity, the second and third time is for verification of facts.

[Gold9472]

I watched it again. Very well done... some parts didn't fit... "needs more than a building"... what did she mean by that? There are other things to focus on? If that's the case, then that statement should be left out... because 9/11 Truth would stop all of the insanity... all by itself. If she meant the destruction of a building was wrong, then I guess that's ok... it's hard to know without having seen it.

[Gold9472]

The other thing was the flash of Silverstein making money, and then the wargames... I think it would be better if you had a picture of Professor Jones on Tucker Carlson... or the KUTV interview... that would be cool.

[Dural]

The building she's referring to is parliment (i.e. Congress), signifying revolution. This isn't exactly a timeline issue, as its explained by the conversation between V and Evey, but I know what you mean.

As far as media generation, remember that I'm confined to the audio track, namely the clicking sound which separates each short screen. An audio or video clip wouldn't work here.

[Gold9472]

The building she's referring to is parliment (i.e. Congress). This isn't exactly a timeline issue, as its explained by the conversation between V and Evey, but I know what you mean.

As far as media generation, remember that I'm confined to the audio track, namely the clicking sound which separates each short screen. An audio or video clip wouldn't work here.

Isn't there a picture of Professor Jones on MSNBC with a headline that says, "Physicist claims, etc...."?

[Dural]

The screens are very easy to change, so I'll look around. I'm not sure if that qualifies as a "coincidence", though. I do show st911.org in the "seek as I seek" part, as well as the ending.

[Gold9472]

The screens are very easy to change, so I'll look around. I'm not sure if that qualifies as a "coincidence", though. I do show st911.org in the "seek as I seek" part, as well as the ending.

True. You don't HAVETA do it, it was just a suggesiton.

[Dural]

One thing I'd like to do is get those web screens pasted onto the screen he's looking at in the movie...I'm not sure how to do that, though.

[Gold9472]

One thing I'd like to do is get those web screens pasted onto the screen he's looking at in the movie...I'm not sure how to do that, though.

Final Cut Pro.

Of course, you're missing one major component in the film. A plug for The 9/11 Truther Forum...

[Dural]

I'm on a homebuilt PC, couldn't pirate FCP if I wanted to. :p I know there's software that can do it for Windows, Sony Vegas 5 (what I'm using) may even be able to do it, I just don't know how. Something to look into, because I think it would solve the worst transition and add to the production value.

[Gold9472]

Video editing is one of the hardest things to do on a computer. You really have to LEARN the software. That's why I like iMovie...

[somebigguy]

Hey Dural, looks good, but needs more 9/11 and less Vendetta in my opinion. Let me know when its done, I'd love to post it up at 911podcasts.com.

[Dural]

Thanks. I'll work on finding video clips to replace a lot of the still images (I
think they hinder the flow) and look into getting the images onto the screen. Not sure how long it will take.

[DemBruceLeeStylez!]

This is class, excellent job!!! I haven’t seen V for Vendetta yet, but I didn’t know the dialog was so blatantly 9/11-truth like that, this video makes the comparison superbly though, very well done!!

[awepittance]

Hey Dural, looks good, but needs more 9/11 and less Vendetta in my opinion. Let me know when its done, I'd love to post it up at 911podcasts.com.

i agree, V for vendetta was meant to be a lot less allegorical than you are making it seem. The book was written in the early 1980s, and imo if you want a better parellel to 9/11 check out Alan moore's other more well known comic Watchmen.

but its good for what it is, i cant really talk since i havent made any 911 films (yet)